‘All of a Sudden’ Review (LFF)

Ryusuke Hamaguchi’s latest is a tender drama about care in all its forms. Largely dialogue driven and buoyed by two luminous lead performances, those who can relax into the slow pace of its 196-minute runtime (head to a cinema with comfy seating) will find themselves rewarded.

We meet Marie-Lou (Virginie Efira), the director of a care facility for the elderly who is attempting to introduce a new approach to and humanise interactions between carer and cared-for with greater dignity, but is coming up against friction from some of the old hands in the overstretched work force. Deeply committed to her vocation, Marie-Lou often stays on-site, barely sleeping in favour of working instead. On her journey home one day, she spots Tomoki (Kodai Kurosaki), an autistic young man alone out by the road. She follows him into the park, making a connection with him and staying by his side after activating a GPS tracker she finds in his jacket pocket. Soon, his grandfather, Goro (Kyōzō Nagatsuka) arrives with his friend and theatre director, Mari (Tao Okamoto). Grateful, Mari invites Marie-Lou to a performance of the play she has directed, starring Goro as the lead. Marie-Lou attends and is touched by its own portrayal of care, she connects with Mari during the post-show Q and A where Mari reveals to her that she has stage four cancer. The two spend the night walking and talking, first along the Seine, then later at the care home as Marie-Lou is called into work. The film follows their conversations as a friendship blossoms and the two have their worldviews reshaped as they learn more about the different meanings of care from one another.

This is a beautiful film about big ideas but focused on the distinct humanity at the heart of each of them. The bulk of the film is simply the two women talking and their meandering, at times philosophical conversations draw you in. The film rests on that transcendent, almost cosmic, feeling of those immediate connections that can be made between people and the importance of those. The pair say to each other multiple times that they don’t know much about the other, speaking about the tangible facts of their life, be it family or past relationships, but there is a strong, undeniable sense of recognition between the pair. They understand each other and come to see each other’s worldviews, even if they don’t know all of the practical details of one another’s lives. Their conversations flow easily and naturally from one topic to the next, even if the rare subject is explored so in-depth that it occasionally feels lecture-like before the point is brought back to the characters and the emotional resonance resounds. Marie-Lou shows Mari the ways she approaches care in the facility, breaking down the reasons for each approach in a way that strips it back to the humanity at its centre and becomes a touching moment of deep recognition between the pair. Mari teaches Marie-Lou the ways to care for herself, to see the benefits in that and how that care can then extend to others. She later becomes more directly involved with the facility itself where her unconventional thinking and methods prove winning amongst the residents.

Efira and Okamoto are absolutely luminous in their roles. Each brings an easy openness to their character and the alchemy of their performances is so that they are hard to extricate and view as two separate efforts. They feel as one, the way Marie-Lou and Mari almost do in the way they appear to totally see one another. They easily convey the depth of their characters and the subtle ways they reveal those depths within one another as their relationship evolves. They keep the film compelling with a naturalistic style, also frequently switching between French (Marie-Lou’s native tongue) and Japanese (Mari’s), adding an additional layer of intimacy.

All elements of the filmmaking work in harmony to paint this believable world, drawing you in so that you feel like the silent observer sharing the space with Marie-Lou and Mari. It is beautiful both emotionally and visually. Despite the clear incoming tragedy of Mari’s illness, the film never overwhelms with heightened dramatics. It moves with a lightness of touch, allowing us to see this experience through the eyes of Marie-Lou and Mari who each, in a different way, take a pragmatic, but in no way unfeeling approach; life is the focus here. It steers entirely clear of melodrama, clear-eyed with its wholesome and kind view of the world yet still managing to ground every moment in authenticity. You truly believe these characters exist beyond the confines of the film’s runtime.

The film’s runtime is definitely felt, often in a meditative way but it does occasionally drag. With its languid pacing, it will reward those who can sink into its slow rhythms, but at 196 minutes, it is testing at times, particularly towards its end. It will undoubtedly be too much for some; this is certainly a film for those who enjoy slow cinema. However, even if at moments you find yourself feeling the minutes, it all pays off in the end. The film’s final moments gently bring home the impact we can have in our lives, and how the way we have affected others can live on after we are gone. It is a beautiful culmination of what has come before.

A beautifully-rendered, meditative piece featuring two astonishingly alchemic performances, All of a Sudden is a study in care, connection and humanity, even if its extended runtime can weaken a few moments.

Leave a Reply